RFE

Sample EB-1 RFE Response Strategy: What USCIS Expects in 2025

by

Receiving a Request for Evidence (RFE) on your EB-1 extraordinary ability green card petition can be stressful. While an RFE is not a denial, it is an opportunity to strengthen your case and address USCIS concerns. In 2025, USCIS continues to apply stricter review standards for EB-1 petitions. Knowing what officers expect and how to respond can make the difference between approval and denial. Below, we answer the most frequently asked questions (FAQs) about EB-1 RFE responses and share strategies that work in 2025.

What Is an EB-1 RFE?

An RFE is a notice from USCIS stating that your EB-1 green card petition lacks sufficient proof. Instead of denying your case, USCIS gives you the chance to submit additional documents or legal arguments.

Why Did I Get an EB-1 RFE?

Common reasons include:

  • Weak documentation of extraordinary ability criteria (media coverage, judging, original contributions).
  • Lack of evidence for a leading or critical role in your organization.
  • Questions about whether your work has national or international acclaim.
  • Inconsistencies with prior immigration filings or resumes.
  • Failure to satisfy the final merits determination standard.

What Does USCIS Expect in an EB-1 RFE Response in 2025?

In 2025, USCIS expects:

  • Clear, organized evidence addressing each concern raised.
  • Objective third party proof, such as media articles, industry statistics, or letters from independent experts.
  • Detailed recommendation letters showing how your work impacts the industry.
  • Legal arguments that connect your evidence directly to USCIS’s EB-1 criteria.
  • Evidence that demonstrates sustained national or international recognition, not just isolated achievements.

What Should a Strong EB-1 RFE Response Include?

A successful EB-1 RFE response should include:

  • Cover letter/brief outlining your legal arguments.
  • Organized exhibits (labeled and indexed for USCIS review).
  • New or stronger evidence of extraordinary ability.
  • Clarifications for any inconsistencies USCIS identified.
  • Extra criteria evidence to go beyond the minimum three, strengthening your case.

Can You Provide a Sample EB-1 RFE Response Strategy?

Yes while every case is different, here’s a sample strategy:

  1. Identify USCIS concerns (“USCIS states that your media coverage is insufficient”).
  2. Address each concern directly (submit additional independent media articles, circulation data, and expert commentary).
  3. Add supplemental evidence to strengthen weaker areas (for example, if “high salary” was questioned, add industry reports comparing your pay).
  4. Cite USCIS policy and case law to support why your evidence qualifies.
  5. Organize the response so officers can easily follow your arguments.

How Much Time Do I Have to Respond?

Typically, USCIS gives you 87 days to respond to an EB-1 RFE. Missing the deadline almost always results in denial.

Can I Win an EB-1 Case After an RFE?

Yes. Many applicants win EB-1 approvals after an RFE. In fact, some of the strongest cases come after USCIS challenges applicants to provide clearer, stronger evidence.

Should I Hire a Lawyer for My EB-1 RFE?

Yes. Responding to an RFE is often more complex than the original filing. We can:

  • Review the RFE and identify weaknesses.
  • Gather new, targeted evidence.
  • Draft persuasive legal arguments.
  • Organize your response for maximum impact.

Don’t Risk a Denial. Let Us Fight for Your Green Card

An EB-1 RFE in 2025 is not the end of the road. It’s an opportunity to rebuild and win your case. With the right response strategy, many applicants overcome RFEs and achieve EB-1 approval. If you’ve received an EB-1 RFE, don’t take chances. Contact us at 305-515-0613 or email info@messersmithlaw.com today. We have successfully responded to EB-1 RFEs and won approvals for clients worldwide.

How to Succeed in Your U.S. Immigration Journey: RFEs, NOIDs, NOIRs, Denials, and Success Stories

by

Immigrating to the United States is a dream for millions, but the process is often filled with challenges like Requests for Evidence (RFE), Notices of Intent to Deny (NOID), Notices of Intent to Revoke (NOIR), and even petition denials. If you’ve received one of these, don’t panic. There are proven ways to respond, appeal, and still succeed. In this article, we’ll break down what each notice means, how to respond effectively, and share real immigration success stories that inspire hope.

What Is an RFE in US Immigration?

An RFE is issued by USCIS when they need more information before making a decision. This doesn’t mean your case is weak. It simply means USCIS wants clarification or additional proof.

Common reasons for RFEs include:

  • Missing documents (birth certificates, translations, or work experience letters)
  • Lack of evidence of extraordinary ability in EB-1A or NIW petitions
  • Incomplete financial records in marriage based or business visas

Always respond before the deadline with strong, well organized evidence. A powerful legal argument plus clear documentation can turn an RFE into an approval.

What Is a NOID and Why Is It Serious?

A NOID means USCIS has reviewed your application and plans to deny it unless you can overcome their concerns.

Common NOID triggers include:

  • USCIS doubts the authenticity of employment history (common in H-1B, EB-1, or OPT fraud related cases)
  • Insufficient evidence of eligibility (not proving “extraordinary ability” or “national interest”)
  • Questions about good faith marriage in family petitions

A NOID requires a strategic, evidence heavy response. We have successfully helped many applicants win approval after submitting expert legal briefs with citations to USCIS policy and federal court cases.

What Is a NOIR and How Does It Differ?

A NOIR is issued after a petition has already been approved, but USCIS has found new information suggesting the approval may have been made in error. This often happens in employment based cases or marriage based petitions.

Reasons for a NOIR may include:

  • Fraud or misrepresentation discovered after approval
  • A petitioner withdrawing support or no longer qualifying
  • A site visit or compliance check revealing discrepancies

NOIRs are very serious because they can undo an approval you’ve already received. However, you still have the opportunity to respond with documentation and legal arguments to preserve your status.

Immigration Denials: What Are Your Options?

If USCIS denies your case, it’s not always the end. Depending on the type of petition, you may be able to:

  • File an appeal with the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO)
  • Submit a Motion to Reopen or Reconsider (MTR)
  • Re-file with stronger evidence

Many denials happen because applicants try to file without legal help, use weak templates, or don’t understand what USCIS is really looking for.

NIW, EB-1A & Other Success Stories

One of the most searched immigration topics today is “NIW success stories” and “EB-1A approval examples.”

Real examples include:

  • A scientist with just 20 publications but strong citation metrics and powerful recommendation letters received an RFE on his EB-1A petition. With our guidance, we built a compelling response that convinced USCIS and secured his approval.
  • A software engineer leading global teams had his EB-1A denied after filing on his own. We took his case on appeal, presented clear evidence of his critical role and industry wide impact, and successfully won the approval.
  • A healthcare researcher received a NOID on a National Interest Waiver petition. By demonstrating the far reaching significance of their contributions to public health policy, we overcame the challenge and achieved approval.
  • A family based petition was issued a NOIR. The clients turned to us, and we assembled robust evidence proving the good faith nature of the marriage, resulting in a successful outcome.

These stories show that even if your case seems weak, the right strategy can turn it around.

How to Respond to an RFE, NOID, NOIR, or Denial

Receiving an RFE, NOID, NOIR, or denial can feel overwhelming, but it’s also an opportunity to strengthen your case. The key is knowing how to respond strategically. The response requires a carefully crafted legal argument backed by solid evidence.

At our firm, we don’t just send documents. We:

  1. Analyze the USCIS concerns in detail and identifying exactly what is missing or misunderstood.
  2. Gather targeted evidence such as expert letters, publications, financial records, or compliance proof, tailored to USCIS’s objections.
  3. Build a legal strategy citing regulations, USCIS policy, and federal case law to directly address the government’s issues.
  4. Organize everything professionally presenting the response in a clear, compelling format that makes it easy for an officer to approve.

Many denials and revocations happen because applicants respond with generic documents or without understanding the law. USCIS is looking for precise, persuasive answers not volume.

We have helped clients turn RFEs into approvals, overcome NOIDs, defeat NOIRs, and even reverse denials on appeal. By combining legal expertise with deep knowledge of immigration policy, we maximize your chance of success.

Don’t Give Up on Your Immigration Dream

Every year, thousands of applicants face RFEs, NOIDs, NOIRs, and denials but many still succeed with the right approach. Whether you are applying for an H-1B, NIW, EB-1A, marriage green card, or waiver, remember: immigration is a process, not a one shot attempt.

An RFE, NOID, NOIR, or denial doesn’t have to be the end of your immigration journey. With the right strategy, many cases can be turned around and we’ve done it for scientists, engineers, researchers, and families just like yours. Our team knows how to analyze USCIS’s concerns, gather powerful evidence, and craft the legal arguments that win.

Don’t leave your future to chance and let us fight for your approval. If you’ve received an RFE, NOID, NOIR, or denial or want to improve your chances of approval on the first try, don’t risk your future by going it alone. Contact us today at 305-515-0613 or email info@messersmithlaw.com . Let us fight to protect your immigration future and help you secure your green card. and let’s turn this challenge into your approval.

H-1B and I-485 RFE, Notice of Intent to Deny or Denial Due to Incorrect Information Provided on Resume: What You Need to Know

by

When applying for an H-1B visa or an I-485 green card adjustment of status, every detail in your petition matters. One of the most common and frustrating issues applicants face is a Request for Evidence (RFE), Notice of Intent to Deny (NOID), or even a denial because of incorrect information provided on the resume.

If you recently received an H-1B or I-485 RFE, NOID, or denial for this reason, you are not alone. USCIS takes accuracy very seriously, and even a small inconsistency can trigger concerns about misrepresentation, eligibility, or the credibility of your case.

Why Resume Information Matters in H-1B and I-485 Cases

  • Work Experience Claims – If your resume lists employers, job titles, or dates that don’t match official records, USCIS may question whether you meet the specialty occupation or experience requirements.
  • Education Background – A mismatch between resume details and degree transcripts can raise red flags.
  • Skills & Certifications – Inflated or misstated credentials can be viewed as misrepresentation.
  • Employment Gaps – Unexplained or incorrectly presented time periods may prompt USCIS to question status maintenance.

Common Triggers for an RFE, NOID, or Denial

  1. H-1B Visa Applications
    • Dates of prior employment that do not match payroll or tax records.
    • Experience letters that contradict resume claims.
    • Education details that differ from transcripts or degree evaluations.
  2. I-485 Adjustment of Status
    • Past employment inconsistencies revealed through background checks.
    • Overstating roles or responsibilities to qualify for a category.
    • Listing employers later identified as fraudulent or dissolved.

How to Respond to an RFE or NOID

Responding to an RFE or NOID is not just about sending more paperwork. It’s about building a cohesive legal argument that convinces USCIS your case deserves approval. Many applicants try to respond on their own or with generic templates and end up facing denials because the response lacked strategy, evidence, or proper legal framing.

The difference between approval and denial often comes down to the quality of your response. A well prepared package can turn a weak case into a winning one. We’ve successfully helped clients overturn NOIDs, overcome RFEs, and even salvage cases that other law firms had given up on.

Denial and Next Steps

If your case is denied due to resume inaccuracies:

  • Appeal or Motion to Reopen/Reconsider – File with USCIS or the Administrative Appeals Office.
  • Refiling – In some cases, correcting the record and refiling is the fastest path.
  • Waivers – If USCIS alleges willful misrepresentation under INA §212(a)(6)(C)(i), a waiver may be needed in limited circumstances.

How Our Law Firm Can Help

We have helped many clients overcome H-1B RFEs and NOIDs and successfully respond to I-485 challenges involving resume discrepancies. Our team:

  • Reviews every detail of your petition for consistency.
  • Builds strong documentary evidence to resolve USCIS concerns.
  • Prepares persuasive legal arguments citing USCIS policy and case law.

Turn RFES or NOIDS Into Approvals With Our Help

An H-1B or I-485 RFE, NOID, or denial caused by incorrect resume information can feel devastating but it does not have to end your immigration journey. With the right strategy, documentation, and legal representation, we have successfully helped many people succeed. Contact us today at 305-515-0613 or email info@messersmithlaw.com to discuss your case.

How to Handle an RFE or NOID

by

What is an RFE?

A Request for Evidence or RFE is a second chance to get your case approved by USCIS.  If USCIS determines that the initial application did not contain all required initial evidence or that the evidence submitted does not demonstrate eligibility, an RFE will be issued asking the applicant or petitioner to submit additional documentation.  In some instances an application or petition will be denied without requesting additional evidence but this is extremely rare.   In other cases where USCIS is predisposed to denying an application or petition, it will issue a Notice of Intent to Deny (NOID).  In most cases USCIS will allow 87 days to prepare and file a response to an RFE.

What is a NOID?

A Notice of Intent to Deny or NOID is much harsher than an RFE.  An NOID is issued after USCIS reviewed an application or petition and either 1. believes there is no basis to approve the case or 2. USCIS has other negative evidence, that it may or may not share with the applicant or petitioner, that may render the applicant ineligible.  In most cases USCIS will allow 30 days to prepare and file a response to an NOID.

Why Did USCIS issue an RFE or NOID?

The reasons for the RFE or NOID will depend on the type of application or petition submitted.  For example, if the request relates to an 1-129 petition such as an H1B, USCIS may question whether the position is truly a specialty position or whether or not there is a true employer-employee relationship between the petitioner and beneficiary.  If the request related to an I-140 petition such as an EB1 or NIW, USCIS may question whether the beneficiary’s educational credentials qualify as an advanced degree or if the beneficiary’s professional accomplishments meet the minimum requirements for the petition.

What Should I Do if I Get an RFE or NOID?

First of all, just because you received an RFE or NOID doesn’t mean that you or your attorney did anything wrong.  Your application or petition may have been prepared thoroughly and the adjudicating officer did not review everything or misapplied the laws or regulations.  Getting an RFE or NOID can be an opportunity to reintroduced already submitted documentation and giving them greater emphasis to ensure the adjudicating officer understands their importance.

How Should I Respond to an RFE or NOID?

Most RFEs or NOIDs are complicated and require a certain expertise to handle.  You should be mindful of the the response deadline and understand that your response to their inquiry is likely the last chance you will have to get your case approved unless you are interested in going through the long and difficult appeals process.  Strategy is key in handling your response and we have been handling RFE and NOID responses for almost 20 years.  A well documented, convincing and thoroughly prepared application is the only way to win in either situation.  We have won many difficult cases.  If you would like our expert help, please feel free to email your RFE or NOID to info@messersmithlaw.com or call us at 305 515 0613.   We look forward to winning your case for you.

Texas Service Center Operations

by

In a recent question and answer session, the Texas Service Center (TSC) has made some revelations regarding how they process certain immigrant and nonimmigrant petitions.

  • Motion to Reopen; Motion to Reconsider; Appeals

When filing a motion to reopen or reconsider, the officer who originally made the decision to deny the underlying case will decide the motion.  If the offier decides to deny the motion, the decision will be reviewed by a supervisor.  Where an appeal is made, the TSC will not reopen or reconsider where the Service believes it made a correct decision but will forward the appeal to the AAO.

  • Petition Denials without RFE or NOID

When an officer decides to deny a petition without sending a request for evidence or notice of intent to deny, that offier’s decision must reviewed by two supervisors before the denial notice will be issued.

  • Notice to Appear Issuance upon I-485 Denial

Generally, the TSC will wait 30 days after issuing an I-485 denial before dispatching a notice to appear (NTA).  This 30 day period provides the Applicant with an opportunity to appeal the denial before being sent to removal proceedings.